Creatine · Ranking
The 22 best creatine supplements of 2026, ranked by testing and price
We compared 22 creatine powders, capsules, chews and gummies sold in the US on third-party testing, price per 5 g, dose accuracy, form and availability. Every price is the regular one-time price on the brand's own US store (or a major retailer where the brand doesn't sell direct), checked Nov 18, 2026. Black Friday promotions were excluded.
Last updated · How we score · No paid placement
Top picks
-
Best overall
BulkSupplements.com Creatine Monohydrate (Micronized) Powder – 1 kg
100.0/100 · $0.15 per 5 g
Top score in our ranking and the lowest price per 5 g we found. It holds NSF Certified for Sport listings, but the brand page doesn't mention them, so match your bag's lot number at nsfsport.com.
-
Best value
Naked Nutrition Naked Creatine – Creatine Monohydrate Powder, Unflavored (2.2 lb / 200 servings)
87.5/100 · $0.18 per 5 g
Single-ingredient monohydrate at $0.18 per 5 g with an NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification (per the brand page). Only BulkSupplements costs less.
-
Best gummy
Force Factor Creatine Monohydrate Gummies (150 ct, 30 servings)
78.2/100 · $1.00 per 5 g
The only gummy here that is NSF Certified for Sport for all lots and measured above label (6.3 g vs 5 g) in SuppCo's 2025 test. Still about 7× the cost of the cheapest powder, with roughly 5–6 g sugar.
-
Best for tested athletes
Thorne Creatine (Unflavored) – 180 Servings
90.5/100 · $0.47 per 5 g
NSF Certified for Sport with named listings, a single ingredient, and wide retail availability. If you are drug-tested, confirm your lot on nsfsport.com before use.
Full ranking
Scores are out of 100: purity and testing (35), value per 5 g (25), dose accuracy and transparency (20), form and ingredients (10), and availability (10). The full rubric is on our methodology page.
| Official link | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BulkSupplements.comCreatine Monohydrate (Micronized) Powder – 1 kg | 100.0 | $0.15 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | bulksupplements.com |
| 2 | ThorneCreatine (Unflavored) – 180 Servings | 90.5 | $0.47 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | thorne.com |
| 3 | MomentousCreatine – 90 Servings (Signature Spec, Unflavored) | 88.3 | $0.48 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | livemomentous.com |
| 4 | Naked NutritionNaked Creatine – Creatine Monohydrate Powder, Unflavored (2.2 lb / 200 servings) | 87.5 | $0.18 | powder | NSF/ANSI 173 (brand-stated) | nakednutrition.com |
| 5 | Garden of Life (Nestlé Health Science)Sport Creatine + Probiotics Powder (Unflavored, ~60 servings, 348 g) | 87.2 | $0.55 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | gardenoflife.com |
| 6 | Animal (Universal Nutrition)Animal Micronized Creatine (Unflavored, 1000 g) | 86.6 | $0.26 | powder | NSF/ANSI 173 | animalpak.com |
| 7 | Klean Athlete (Nestlé Health Science)Klean Creatine (Unflavored, 315 g) | 86.2 | $0.55 | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | kleanathlete.com |
| 8 | Optimum NutritionMicronized Creatine Powder (Unflavored, 240 Servings / 2.64 lb) | 82.6 | $0.23 | powder | Informed Choice | optimumnutrition.com |
| 9 | Force FactorCreatine Monohydrate Gummies (150 ct, 30 servings) | 78.2 | $1.00 | gummy | NSF Certified for Sport | forcefactor.com |
| 10 | Transparent LabsCreatine HMB (60 Servings) | 77.8 | $1.50 | powder | NSF Sport (unverified) | transparentlabs.com |
| 11 | PuoriC+ – Creatine+ Performance Support (60 servings) | 75.9 | $0.57 | powder | Clean Label Project | puori.com |
| 12 | CON-CRĒTCON-CRĒT® Creatine HCl Powder – Unflavored (100 Servings) | 67.4 | $2.25* | powder | NSF Certified for Sport | con-cret.com |
| 13 | Micro IngredientsMicronized Creatine Monohydrate Powder – Unflavored (1 KG) | 66.4 | $0.23 | powder | Brand claim only | microingredients.com |
| 14 | NutricostCreatine Monohydrate Powder (Unflavored, 1 KG) | 66.3 | $0.23 | powder | Brand claim only | nutricost.com |
| 15 | MuscleTechPlatinum 100% Creatine (Unflavored, 400 g / 80 servings) | 64.6 | $0.29 | powder | Brand claim only | muscletech.com |
| 16 | Create WellnessCreatine Monohydrate Gummies – Tub (90 ct) | 64.5 | $2.22 | gummy | NSF Certified for Sport | trycreate.co |
| 17 | Optimum NutritionMicronized Creatine Capsules (100 Servings / 200 Capsules) | 64.0 | $0.80 | capsule | Informed Choice | optimumnutrition.com |
| 18 | MomentousCreatine Chews 150-Count | 62.9 | $1.67 | chewable tablet | NSF Sport badge (unverified) | livemomentous.com |
| 19 | Legion AthleticsCreatine Gummies (30 servings) | 62.8 | $1.33 | gummy | Labdoor (brand-paid) | legionathletics.com |
| 20 | KagedCreatine HCl™ (75 Servings) | 61.5 | $2.50* | powder | Informed Sport (brand-stated) | kaged.com |
| 21 | CellucorCellucor® Unflavored COR-Performance® Creatine Powder (72 Servings) | 60.3 | $0.26 | powder | None confirmed | cellucor.com |
| 22 | Bear BalancedCreatine Gummies (Blueberry; 30 servings / 90 gummies) | 51.4 | $2.86 | gummy | Published COAs | creatinegummies.com |
*CON-CRĒT and Kaged are creatine HCl. Their price is per 5 g of monohydrate-equivalent creatine (HCl is about 78% creatine by weight vs about 88% for monohydrate). Both brands recommend smaller doses; evidence that smaller HCl doses match 3–5 g of monohydrate is limited.
Key takeaways
- Cheapest isn't worst here. BulkSupplements' 1 kg bag is the lowest price per 5 g in our list ($0.15) and holds NSF Certified for Sport listings. Its own product page doesn't mention this, so check the lot number.
- Premium certified tubs cost about 3× more. Thorne, Momentous, Klean Athlete and Garden of Life all hold NSF Certified for Sport and cost $0.47–$0.55 per 5 g. Momentous says it no longer uses Creapure as of 2026.
- Good value without a sport certification: Naked (NSF/ANSI 173, brand-stated), Animal (NSF/ANSI 173) and Optimum Nutrition powder (Informed Choice). Nutricost, Micro Ingredients, MuscleTech and Cellucor cost about the same but have no public third-party certification we could confirm.
- HCl costs more per gram of creatine. CON-CRĒT and Kaged are certified, but a 750 mg scoop is far below the 3–5 g/day monohydrate dose that has been studied most.
- Gummies are a gamble unless certified. Several independent rounds from 2024–2025 found gummies with little or no creatine. The certified gummies we ranked cost $1.00–$2.86 per 5 g, versus $0.15 for the cheapest powder, and add sugar or sugar alcohols.
All 22 creatine supplements, reviewed
Tags: Unverified means the research could not confirm the claim against a registry or label. Brand-stated means the source is the brand itself.
BulkSupplements.com Creatine Monohydrate (Micronized) Powder – 1 kg
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None (bag; no scoop-tub). Flavored 700 g versions also NSF-listed.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$29.97 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.15 per 5 g
Brand store: 100 g $17.97, 250 g $20.97, 500 g $22.97, 1 kg $29.97; Amazon 1 kg $27.97.
Pros
- Lowest price per 5 g in this list
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Huge Amazon review base
Cons
- Resealable bag, serving measured by teaspoon (brand notes serving sizes may change)
- Brand page does not mention the NSF certification – verify lot at nsfsport.com
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings 1676955 and 1796571; check lot number)
Check before you buy
- The NSF listing is lot-specific and not mentioned on the brand page. Match your bag's lot number at nsfsport.com.
Thorne Creatine (Unflavored) – 180 Servings
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None (unflavored). Flavored Strawberry/Pineapple Orange versions (60 servings, $48) add natural flavor, citric acid, malic acid, rebaudioside M (stevia-derived), beet juice color.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$84.00 one-time for 180 servings (900 g) · $0.47 per 5 g
Brand site: $84 / 180 scoops; 90-serving tub $44 (=$0.49 per 5 g).
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport with named lots
- Single ingredient
- Wide retail availability (Amazon, Walmart, Mayo Clinic store)
Cons
- About 3x the price per 5 g of the cheapest certified option (BulkSupplements)
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings 1204244 and 1495542)
- NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification (Thorne facility listing)
Momentous Creatine – 90 Servings (Signature Spec, Unflavored)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate ('Signature Spec'; brand states it no longer uses Creapure®), 5 g per serving. None.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$42.99 one-time for 90 servings (450 g) · $0.48 per 5 g
One-time $42.99; subscription $32.24. Product page showed 'Estimated to be back in stock: Soon' for one-time purchase on 2026-11-18.
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport, all lots
- Publishes per-batch COAs
- Single ingredient
Cons
- Switched away from Creapure in 2026 (older reviews/retail pages still say Creapure)
- Stock interruptions seen on brand site
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listing 1285010, all lots)
- Brand states batch results published and extra PFAS/microplastics screening Brand-stated
Check before you buy
- The one-time purchase option showed “Estimated to be back in stock: Soon” on Nov 18, 2026.
Naked Nutrition Naked Creatine – Creatine Monohydrate Powder, Unflavored (2.2 lb / 200 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized, 200 mesh), 5 g per serving. None (unflavored). Flavored Strawberry/Lemon Lime/Orange versions: 90 servings of 11 g scoops.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$35.99 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.18 per 5 g
Brand store $35.99 one-time (1 kg); 1.1 lb ~$21.99–22.99.
Pros
- Single ingredient
- Low price per 5 g
- NSF contents certification
Cons
- NSF 173 checks contents/contaminants but is not the Certified for Sport banned-substance program
Certification
- NSF Contents Certified (NSF/ANSI 173) per brand page Brand-stated
- Informed Choice (reported by SuppCo; not verified here) Unverified
Check before you buy
- Informed Choice status was reported by SuppCo but not verified by us; it is not scored.
Garden of Life Sport Creatine + Probiotics Powder (Unflavored, ~60 servings, 348 g)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized; NutraAssure iCreatine per retailer label), 5 g per serving. Per 5.8 g scoop: 5 g creatine monohydrate + Bacillus subtilis DE111® (1 billion CFU, 10 mg).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$32.79 one-time for 60 servings (300 g) · $0.55 per 5 g
Brand store $32.79; Amazon $28.69; PureFormulas $24.39.
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Non-GMO Project Verified
Cons
- Added probiotic raises price; no established benefit of pairing with creatine
- Mid-high price per 5 g
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listing 1580463)
- Non-GMO Project Verified
- NSF Certified Gluten-Free
- Kosher
Animal Micronized Creatine (Unflavored, 1000 g)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$50.95 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.26 per 5 g
Brand store: 300 g $18.50, 500 g $26.75, 1000 g $50.95.
Pros
- Single ingredient
- NSF contents certification
- Made in brand's own US GMP facility
Cons
- Not on NSF Certified for Sport / Informed lists
- Mid-range price per 5 g
Certification
- NSF/ANSI 173 contents certification (Universal Nutrition listing); not NSF Certified for Sport
Klean Athlete Klean Creatine (Unflavored, 315 g)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (retailer labels list Creapure®), 5 g per serving. None.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$34.50 one-time for 63 servings (315 g) · $0.55 per 5 g
2026 SRP $34.50 (brand price list; also PureFormulas and Amazon $34.50). Label says 'approx. 60' servings; 315 g / 5 g = 63 used here. Brand site requires an account to buy.
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Single ingredient
- Creapure® per retailer labels
Cons
- Smaller tub; mid-high price per 5 g
- Creapure sourcing shown on retailer/older labels but not on every current brand page (uncertain)
- Brand store is account-gated
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings 1121640 and 1780369)
Check before you buy
- Creapure sourcing appears on retailer and older labels but not on every current brand page.
- Label says “approx. 60” servings; we used 315 g ÷ 5 g = 63.
Optimum Nutrition Micronized Creatine Powder (Unflavored, 240 Servings / 2.64 lb)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None (unflavored). Flavored 60-serving versions (Mango Orange, Strawberry, Watermelon Lime, Blueberry Lemonade) use 6 g scoops and state no artificial flavors, colors or sweeteners.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$53.99 one-time for 240 servings (1200 g) · $0.23 per 5 g
Brand store: 60 serv $20.49, 120 serv $31.99, 240 serv $53.99.
Pros
- Low price per 5 g from a major brand
- Informed Choice certified
- Sold almost everywhere
Cons
- Not NSF Certified for Sport
- Informed Choice screens banned substances, not label-claim potency
Certification
- Informed Choice (certified 10-Feb-2020; banned-substance screening of retail lots)
Force Factor Creatine Monohydrate Gummies (150 ct, 30 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate + AstraGin®, 5 g per serving. Per 5 gummies: 5 g creatine monohydrate, 25 mg AstraGin®; tapioca syrup, cane sugar, water, pectin, citric acid, natural flavors, fruit/vegetable juice color, sodium citrate. ~5–6 g sugar.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$29.99 one-time for 30 servings (150 g) · $1.00 per 5 g
Brand site does not sell direct (shows $0.00 per third-party review); Amazon $29.99 (also Walmart, CVS).
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Measured 6.3 g vs 5 g label in SuppCo 2025
- Cheapest gummy per 5 g here
Cons
- 5 gummies/day with ~5–6 g added sugar
- Reported high creatinine in SuppCo test (The Barbell)
- Not sold on own site
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listing 1779617, all lots)
Transparent Labs Creatine HMB (60 Servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate + HMB (myHMB®), 5 g per serving. Per serving: 5 g creatine monohydrate, 1.5 g HMB (myHMB®), vitamin D3 500 IU, 5 mg BioPerine® black pepper extract. 13 flavors; flavored versions use natural flavors and stevia-type sweetener (no artificial sweeteners per brand).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$89.99 one-time for 60 servings (300 g) · $1.50 per 5 g
Brand store: 30 sv $49.99, 60 sv $89.99.
Pros
- Full 5 g creatine plus HMB in one scoop
- Multiple certifications
- Many flavors
Cons
- Most expensive powder per 5 g creatine in this list
- HMB/BioPerine add cost; evidence for added benefit over creatine alone is weaker than for creatine itself
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (per NSF register as reported by third-party reviewers; listing not opened here) Unverified
- Informed Choice (brand claim) Brand-stated
- Labdoor A grade listed
Check before you buy
- NSF Certified for Sport status comes from third-party reviewers; we did not open the NSF listing. Informed Choice is a brand claim.
Puori C+ – Creatine+ Performance Support (60 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate + taurine, 5 g per serving. Per 5.4 g scoop: 5 g creatine monohydrate, 400 mg taurine. Unflavored.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$34.00 one-time for 60 servings (300 g) · $0.57 per 5 g
Brand store $34.00 one-time; $28.90 subscription.
Pros
- Batch-level contaminant and label-claim results published
- Unflavored, two ingredients
Cons
- Not a banned-substance (sport) certification
- Taurine add-on; mid-high price
Certification
- Clean Label Project Certified + Purity Award (Puori certificate DSP0007)
- Per-batch COA (Ellipse Analytics, ISO 17025) – lot 118462 passed label-claim accuracy, heavy metals, pesticides
CON-CRĒT® Creatine HCl Powder – Unflavored (100 Servings)
What it contains
Creatine hydrochloride (patented Creatine HCl), 750 mg per scoop. Unflavored: creatine HCl only. Flavored versions (Orange Cream, Lemon Lime, Raspberry, Pineapple, Hibiscus Breeze) exist.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$29.99 one-time for 100 servings (75 g) · $2.25 per 5 g monohydrate-equivalent
Brand store: 64 servings $24.99, 100 servings $29.99. Brand promotes 'micro-dosing' by body weight; NSF 173 listing gives a daily serving of 5 scoops (3,750 mg).
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Very small scoop, dissolves easily
Cons
- 750 mg per scoop – far below the 3–5 g/day monohydrate dose used in most research
- Claims of superior absorption/no bloating are brand claims; head-to-head evidence vs monohydrate is limited
- Highest cost per 5 g of creatine among powders
- Note: CON-CRĒT gummies (not this powder) failed NOW Foods' 2024 gummy test
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings 1620371, 1693177)
- NSF/ANSI 173 listing
Micro Ingredients Micronized Creatine Monohydrate Powder – Unflavored (1 KG)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. None.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$45.95 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.23 per 5 g
Brand store: 500 g $22.95 (reg. $27.95); 1 kg $39.95 (reg. $45.95). Amazon 1 kg ~$28.99; iHerb/PureFormulas $29.99.
Sale price seen: $39.95 (not used in scoring).
Pros
- Cheap per gram (especially on Amazon/iHerb)
- Single ingredient
Cons
- No public third-party certification found
- Brand-site price higher than marketplaces
Certification
- Brand says ingredients are third-party tested; no NSF/Informed/Labdoor listing found Brand-stated
Nutricost Creatine Monohydrate Powder (Unflavored, 1 KG)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized); separate Creapure® SKU exists, 5 g per serving. Unflavored: none. Many flavors (Blue Raspberry, Fruit Punch, etc.) – sweetener details not confirmed.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$46.97 one-time for 200 servings (1000 g) · $0.23 per 5 g
Brand store: 300 g $18.97, 500 g $23.97, 1 kg $46.97 (500 g is actually cheaper per gram: $0.24 per 5 g). Black Friday code BF2026 (40% off) not applied. Creapure version $42.97.
Pros
- Low price
- Many sizes and flavors
- Retail availability (Amazon, Target, Kroger banners)
Cons
- No NSF/Informed listing found
- Prop 65 lead warning on product page (common on supplements; not a test result)
Certification
- Brand states independent accredited-lab testing (no public certificate found) Brand-stated
Check before you buy
- Nutricost was included in ConsumerLab's June 2026 creatine review, but those results are paywalled and were not used.
MuscleTech Platinum 100% Creatine (Unflavored, 400 g / 80 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. Unflavored: none. Orange Splash, Grape Freeze, Red Berry flavors (sweeteners not confirmed).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$22.99 one-time for 80 servings (400 g) · $0.29 per 5 g
Brand store $22.99 (all flavors). Unflavored 400 g = 80 servings per retailer labels; flavored tubs are 60 servings (Stack3d).
Pros
- Low price
- Big-box availability
Cons
- No third-party certification found
Certification
- Brand states HPLC-tested; no NSF/Informed registry entry found (AllAboutCreatine, Oct 2026) Brand-stated
Check before you buy
- Serving count for the unflavored tub (80) comes from retailer labels; flavored tubs are 60 servings.
Create Wellness Creatine Monohydrate Gummies – Tub (90 ct)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (older pages said Creapure®; current packaging images labelled 'NoCreapure' – uncertain), 4.5 g per serving. Creatine monohydrate, tapioca syrup, sugar, reverse-osmosis water, pectin, allulose, natural flavor, plant colors (turmeric/spirulina), malic and citric acid. ~5 g sugar per 3-gummy serving (NSF listing).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$60.00 one-time for 30 servings (135 g) · $2.22 per 5 g
Brand store: Tub 90 ct $60 (3 gummies = 4.5 g); 30-sachet pouch $72.50. Amazon 90 ct ~$49.98.
Pros
- NSF Certified for Sport
- Passed SuppCo June 2025 test (4.59 g vs 4.5 g label)
- Vegan pectin base
Cons
- Failed NOW Foods' Feb-2024 test (1,278 mg vs 1,500 mg per gummy, ~85%) – brand disputed with its own Eurofins data
- SuppCo found 7,300 ppm creatinine (degradation product)
- 4.5 g serving; ~10x powder cost per 5 g
- Contains sugar
Certification
- NSF Certified for Sport (listings incl. 1782317, 1782313, 1782311 – all lots for most flavors)
Check before you buy
- Older pages said Creapure; current packaging images reference “NoCreapure”. Sourcing is unconfirmed.
Optimum Nutrition Micronized Creatine Capsules (100 Servings / 200 Capsules)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 2.5 g per serving. Gelatin, magnesium stearate (not vegetarian).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$39.99 one-time for 100 servings (250 g) · $0.80 per 5 g
Brand store: 100 caps $22.99, 200 caps $39.99, 300 caps $57.49. Serving = 2 capsules = 2.5 g; 5 g/day = 4 capsules.
Pros
- No mixing
- Informed Choice certified
- Widely stocked (Amazon, Target, grocery)
Cons
- 4 capsules for a 5 g day
- ~3.5x the cost per 5 g of the same brand's powder
- Gelatin capsule
Certification
- Informed Choice (certified 24-Oct-2019)
Momentous Creatine Chews 150-Count
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (Signature Spec), 5 g per serving. Pressed-powder chewable tablet; flavors Lemon Lime, Mango, Strawberry. Full excipient list not confirmed; a third-party review reports glucose (~1 g per chew) – unverified.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$49.99 one-time for 30 servings (150 g) · $1.67 per 5 g
$49.99 one-time for 150 chews (1 g each); 5 chews = 5 g. Subscription $37.49.
Pros
- Pressed tablet rather than a moist gummy (less creatine-degradation risk in principle)
- 1 g per chew makes dosing simple
Cons
- 5 chews per day
- ~3.5x the cost of the brand's powder per 5 g
Certification
- Brand page shows NSF Certified for Sport badge (listing not opened in this research) Unverified
Check before you buy
- NSF Certified for Sport is shown as a badge on the brand page; we did not open the NSF listing.
- A third-party review reports about 1 g glucose per chew; not verified.
Legion Athletics Creatine Gummies (30 servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate, 5 g per serving. Naturally flavored/sweetened. Label conflict: iHerb Lemon Drop panel lists 8 g added sugars and 70 kcal per serving, while Legion's comparison table says 'Zero Sugar' – check current label.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$39.99 one-time for 30 servings (150 g) · $1.33 per 5 g
Brand list $39.99 ($1.33/serving); Amazon $34.95. Gummies per serving differ by flavor/label (5 per iHerb Lemon Drop; 4 per a Green Apple listing).
Pros
- Full 5 g dose verified by Labdoor
- Natural sweeteners, no artificial dyes
Cons
- Not NSF/Informed certified (Labdoor is paid by the brand)
- Sugar content unclear across labels
- Expensive vs powder
Certification
- Labdoor certified (brand-paid): 5,920 mg found vs 5,000 mg claimed, heavy metals below USP limits
Check before you buy
- Labels conflict on sugar (one panel lists 8 g added sugars; the brand's comparison table says zero) and on gummies per serving. Check the current label.
Kaged Creatine HCl™ (75 Servings)
What it contains
Creatine hydrochloride (C-HCl™ / CON-CRĒT® creatine HCl per label), 750 mg per scoop. Unflavored: creatine HCl. Fruit Punch / Lemon Lime add natural flavors and sucralose (per Garage Gym Reviews).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$24.99 one-time for 75 servings (56.2 g) · $2.50 per 5 g monohydrate-equivalent
Regular $24.99; sale $17.49 shown in search snapshot (date of sale not confirmed). Kaged FAQ: 'take four servings daily' (3 g).
Sale price seen: $17.49 (not used in scoring).
Pros
- Informed Sport batch testing
- Small serving volume
Cons
- 750 mg per scoop
- Flavored versions use sucralose
- Expensive per 5 g of creatine
Certification
- Informed Sport (brand: every batch tested) Brand-stated
Check before you buy
- Price comes from a search snapshot of the brand page (the product data could not be loaded directly). The $17.49 sale price was seen but its date is unconfirmed.
Cellucor® Unflavored COR-Performance® Creatine Powder (72 Servings)
What it contains
Creatine monohydrate (micronized), 5 g per serving. Unflavored: none. Flavored and JOLLY RANCHER versions exist (sweeteners not confirmed).
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$18.99 one-time for 72 servings (360 g) · $0.26 per 5 g
Brand store $18.99 one-time (BOGO 40% promo shown). Flavored 50-serving version $17.99.
Pros
- Cheap per 5 g
- Widely available
Cons
- No verified third-party certification for this creatine
Certification
- No creatine-specific certification confirmed (an Informed Choice list snippet mentions 'Cellucor COR-Performanc…' – unverified) Unverified
Check before you buy
- An Informed Choice list entry mentioning “Cellucor COR-Performanc…” could not be matched to this product. Treat it as uncertified.
Bear Balanced Creatine Gummies (Blueberry; 30 servings / 90 gummies)
What it contains
Creapure® creatine monohydrate, 3.5 g per serving. Creapure® creatine, L-theanine, L-tyrosine, vitamin B12, huperzine A, maltitol, water, xylitol, pectin, citric acid, malic acid, Reb M, natural flavor and color. Sugar-free.
Price checked Nov 18, 2026
$60.00 one-time for 30 servings (105 g) · $2.86 per 5 g
Brand store: 1 bag (30 servings) $42 (list $60); multi-bag discounts.
Sale price seen: $42.00 (not used in scoring).
Pros
- Passed independent NOW test and publishes lot COAs
- Sugar-free
- Creapure®
Cons
- 3.5 g per 3-gummy serving (below 5 g)
- Adds nootropic ingredients (huperzine A, tyrosine) not needed for creatine
- Sugar alcohols (maltitol/xylitol) may cause GI upset
- Expensive per 5 g
Certification
- Brand-published Eurofins finished-product COAs (4 lots, 111–115% of 3.5 g label)
- Passed NOW Foods 2024 test (116% of claim)
- Brand says tested by NSF lab under Amazon's verification program (not NSF Certified for Sport) Brand-stated
Creatine gummy lab tests, 2024–2026
Creatine gummies are moist, sweetened products, and creatine can break down into creatinine over time. Independent and semi-independent testing rounds have repeatedly found gummies far below their label claims. Here is every public round we used, with links to the original reports.
-
NOW Foods in-house HPLC testing
6 met label (Bear Balanced, Bod, Effective Nutra, Iron Labs Nutrition, Peach Perfect, Zhou); 6 failed (Astro Labs, Beast Bites, Create, Con-Cret, Greabby, Njord). Con-Cret 28.3 mg vs 250 mg claim; Beast Bites 8.7 mg vs 1,000 mg; Create 1,278 mg vs 1,500 mg. Failing products also contained creatinine.
Caveat: NOW sells creatine and ran the tests itself; single lots.
Sources: wholefoodsmagazine.com · onuroncer.com · supplysidesj.com
-
SuppCo 'Tested' program, ISO 17025 lab
All 5 powders passed (98–101% purity). 4 of 6 gummies failed: Happyummmm 0.005 g vs 5 g per serving (Amazon's Choice best-seller), DivinusLabs 0.025 g vs 5 g, EcoWise and Vidabotan no creatine detected. Create (4.59 g vs 4.5 g) and Force Factor (6.3 g vs 5 g) passed but with notable creatinine.
Sources: supp.co · wired.com · athletechnews.com · isitunderdosed.com
-
Eurofins testing commissioned by UK influencer James Smith
Only Wellboost exceeded claim (5.55 g vs 5 g); three at 95%, 86%, 73%; five had ≤0.11 g per serving (<2% of claim).
Sources: nutraingredients.com
-
Labdoor certificate (brand-paid)
5,920 mg found vs 5,000 mg claimed.
Sources: labdoor.com · getevident.co
What this means if you want a gummy
- Choose a gummy with a current third-party certification or a published independent assay. In our list that means Force Factor (NSF Certified for Sport), Create (NSF Certified for Sport), Legion (Labdoor, brand-paid) or Bear Balanced (published Eurofins COAs).
- Create failed NOW Foods' February 2024 test (about 85% of label) but passed SuppCo's June 2025 test. Results apply to the lots tested.
- Check the serving size: Create gives 4.5 g and Bear Balanced 3.5 g per serving, below 5 g.
Creatine FAQ
What is the best creatine supplement in 2026?
In our ranking, BulkSupplements Creatine Monohydrate scores highest (100/100): it is the cheapest per 5 g we found ($0.15) and holds NSF Certified for Sport listings. If you prefer a widely stocked tub with named NSF Sport listings, Thorne Creatine ($0.47 per 5 g) is our pick for tested athletes. Prices were checked Nov 18, 2026.
Do creatine gummies actually contain creatine?
Not always. In NOW Foods' 2024 testing, 6 of 12 gummy brands failed their label claim. In SuppCo's 2025 test, 4 of 6 gummies failed, including two with no creatine detected. In a 2025 Eurofins round commissioned by James Smith, 5 of 9 brands had 0.11 g or less per serving. Gummies with NSF Certified for Sport (Force Factor, Create) or a Labdoor report (Legion) tested near or above label in the rounds we found.
How much creatine should I take per day?
Creatine monohydrate at 3–5 g per day is the most-studied form and dose. That is why we compare every product on its price per 5 g. Talk to a health professional before starting a supplement, especially if you have a medical condition or take medication.
Is creatine HCl better than creatine monohydrate?
We found no strong head-to-head evidence that it is. Monohydrate is the most-researched form. The two HCl products we ranked (CON-CRĒT and Kaged) provide 750 mg per scoop, well below the 3–5 g/day monohydrate dose used in most research, and they are the most expensive powders per 5 g of creatine in our list.
What is the difference between NSF Certified for Sport, NSF/ANSI 173 and Informed Choice?
NSF Certified for Sport and Informed Sport test lots or batches for banned substances and check the label. NSF/ANSI 173 certification checks contents and contaminants but is not the banned-substance sport program. Informed Choice screens retail lots for banned substances but not label-claim potency. Certification covers the listed lots, flavors and sizes only, so check the registry for your product.
What we couldn't verify
- Prices change often, and Black Friday 2026 promotions were live while we collected them. Check the brand page before you buy.
- Certification is specific to lot, flavor and size, and can lapse. Transparent Labs' and Momentous Chews' NSF Certified for Sport status came from secondary reports or the brand page; we didn't open those NSF listings.
- Cellucor's Informed Choice status is unverified, so we scored it as uncertified.
- ConsumerLab's June 2026 creatine review is paywalled; its results were not used.